Skip to content
Open access

Predicting runoff in data-sparse drylands: a case study evaluating regionalization success for two parsimonious loss models

Sep 2026 · Frontiers in Water · Vol 8 · 0 citations · 56 references

Abstract

Reliable flash flood forecasting is essential for sustainable storm infrastructure planning and hazard mitigation in sensitive dryland landscapes. Loss or infiltration models are central to flash flood prediction in arid watersheds, where runoff is dominated by infiltration excess. Parsimonious models are critical for use in practice. Accurate prediction remains a challenge because calibration data are typically scarce or unavailable. Regionalization can help fill this data gap: model parameters from a physically similar donor basin with available calibration data are transferred to a target watershed with no or limited data. In this study, we tested whether regionalization success depends on model selection. Two simple loss models available in the widely-used HEC-HMS software – the SCS curve number (CN) and the linear-constant (LC) methods – were calibrated and validated based on long-term observations from the Walnut Gulch Experimental Watershed in Arizona. Optimized parameters derived from this donor basin were then transferred to the target basin, a partially urbanized watershed in New Mexico with a dense network of rain and flow gaging stations. The target basin has a limited observational record and therefore serves as a suitable test case for regionalization under data-limited conditions. Validation results from the donor basin demonstrate that the LC model outperformed the CN model for large storm events across four performance metrics. Performance for small events was not significantly different. When parameters were transferred to the target basin and tested for a rare, high-intensity storm event recorded in 2025, the LC model again performed better for most metrics. While regionalization can be a viable strategy to support stormwater infrastructure design in data-scarce, semi-arid urban watersheds, this study indicates that its success depends on model selection.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Variable Source Area (VSA) modeling for water management: streamflow analysis in Upper Gilgel Abay watershed, Ethiopia

Reliable streamflow simulation is fundamental for effective water resources management in data-scarce watersheds, particularly where runoff is dominated by saturation-excess processes that are inadequately represented by many conventional hydrological models. This study evaluates the applicability of the variable sourc...

A. Worku, F. Zimale · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Impact of Land Cover Change on Urban Flooding and Hydraulic Performance of Kinalumsan River, Cebu City, Central Visayas, Philippines

Predicting flood dynamics in data-scarce urban catchments remains a major hydrological challenge, yet physically-based modeling is essential for design mitigation infrastructure. This study assessed the impact of land cover change on the hydrological response and hydraulic performance of the ungauged Kinalumsan River i...

Niña Alyannah Kaye Regidor, F. Boogaard, Taneza Mae A. Bontilao et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Regionalization of Calibrated Curve Number Using Multivariate Regression for Flood Simulation in the Moluccas Islands

Accurate estimation of calibrated Curve Number (CN) is essential for reliable flood simulation, particularly in island watersheds characterized by short hydrological response times, high rainfall variability, and heterogeneous land cover. This study regionalizes calibrated CN values in the Moluccas Islands, Indonesia,...

Hayatuddin Tuasikal, P. Juwono, M. Sholichin et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Linking Rainfall Simulation and Single-Ring Measurements on a Swiss Alpine Hillslope: A Novel Framework for Surface Runoff Estimation

Surface runoff in alpine catchments is sensitive to rainfall intensity, resulting in substantial variations in runoff coefficients across rainfall scenarios. Although this dependency is well documented in the literature, it is often neglected in practical applications by assuming a fixed runoff coefficient for all even...

Julius Nickl, Massimiliano Schwarz, Samuel Storz et al. · 0 citations
Conference Open access Sep 2026

LULC-Based Flood Risk Assessment using Spatial Modeling for Watershed Decision Support

Rapid urbanization in peri-urban watersheds alters hydrological processes and exacerbates downstream flooding by replacing permeable vegetated landscapes with impervious surfaces. Hydrological and hydrodynamic modeling tools often demand extensive calibration datasets that are unavailable in data-limited regions. This...

Suprajaka, Aphrodita Puspateja, Darmawan Listya Cahya et al. · 0 citations
Conference Sep 2026

Climate Change Impact on Surface Water Availability in an Ungauged Basin in Northern Sri Lanka

Reliable assessment of water availability in ungauged catchments remains a major challenge in regions where hydrological observations are sparse. This study investigates the challenges associated with modelling the ungauged Kanakarayan Aru basin in northern Sri Lanka and evaluates potential changes in surface-water ava...

M. Z. Weerabangsa, A. D. Iresh, B. C. .l. Athapattu · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.