Skip to content
#gene editing Review Open access

Deciphering argumentation on the regulation of genome‐edited crops in academic publications: A systematic review

Nov 2026 · Plants, People, Planet · 0 citations · 53 references

Abstract

Genome editing technologies such as CRISPR‐Cas are reshaping debates about the future of agriculture, yet disagreement over how these crops should be regulated remains widespread. This study clarifies the range of arguments used in scientific discussions about genome‐edited crops, making underlying assumptions and value judgements more visible. By mapping and critically analysing this contested landscape, this research supports more transparent, inclusive and informed decision‐making. It is particularly relevant for policymakers, regulators and stakeholders navigating complex choices around innovation, safety and public trust. Ultimately, this work helps foster more balanced and deliberative governance of emerging plant breeding technologies in society. • This study systematically examines the reasons advanced in the academic literature for and against regulatory oversight of gene‐edited crops (GEC) intended for cultivation and commercialisation. It aims to clarify how these reasons are framed, their underlying assumptions and their implications for regulatory debates. • A systematic review of reasons was conducted on 200 peer‐reviewed articles published between 2012 and 2025. Arguments were identified and categorised into technical, agronomic, socio‐economic, health, environmental, legal and ethical domains and their orientation (favourable or unfavourable) and frequency were analysed. • The literature shows a marked asymmetry, with most publications presenting exclusively favourable reasons for GEC, primarily based on technical characteristics and agronomic potential. Unfavourable reasons are less frequent but more specific and detailed. The critical analysis of favourable arguments also reveals recurring simplifications of technical aspects, unclear definitions of key concepts such as sustainability and food security and limited engagement with uncertainty and trade‐offs. Risks and ethical reasoning are comparatively marginal and often expressed indirectly. • The predominance of technical arguments and context‐dependent benefits may limit comprehensive policy assessment and constrain transparent regulatory deliberation. A more balanced evaluation that explicitly addresses uncertainties, trade‐offs and value‐based considerations could better support policymakers in assessing GEd technologies and ensuring societally legitimate outcomes at acceptable levels of risk.

Read PDF

Similar papers

#computer vision Conference Aug 2008

A Preliminary Roadmap for Empirical Research on Agile Software Development

Some claim that especially in the field of agile software development the research lags years behind of the practice. In this paper, we characterize the status and main challenges for research on agile software development, and propose a preliminary roadmap, focusing on providing more empirical research, primarily on e...

Torgeir Dingsøyr, T. Dybå, P. Abrahamsson · 92 citations · ⚡7
#computer vision Book Open access Mar 2017

On the Unhappiness of Software Developers

The results indicate that software developers are a slightly happy population, but the need for limiting the unhappiness of developers remains, and 219 factors representing causes of unhappiness while developing software are identified.

D. Graziotin, Fabian Fagerholm, Xiaofeng Wang et al. · 84 citations · ⚡6
#computer vision Open access Feb 2018

Lean Internal Startups for Software Product Innovation in Large Companies: Enablers and Inhibitors

This study investigates how Lean internal startup facilitates software product innovation in large companies and identifies its enablers and inhibitors, and shows the potential of the method-in-action framework to investigate the Lean startup approach in non-startup context.

Henry Edison, Nina M. Smørsgård, Xiaofeng Wang et al. · 78 citations · ⚡6
#computer vision Review Apr 2024

AI-powered Code Review with LLMs: Early Results

The goal is to not only refine the accuracy of the LLM-based tool but also to underscore its potential in streamlining the software development lifecycle through proactive code improvement and education.

Z. Rasheed, Malik Abdul Sami, Muhammad Waseem et al. · 62 citations · ⚡3
#computer vision Conference Aug 2008

Scrum in a Multiproject Environment: An Ethnographically-Inspired Case Study on the Adoption Challenges

Agile methods continue to gain popularity. In particular, the Scrum method appears to be on the verge of becoming a de-facto standard in the industry, leading the so called Agile movement. While there are success stories and recommendations, there is little scientifically valid evidence of the challenges in the adoptio...

A. Marchenko, P. Abrahamsson · 59 citations · ⚡11

Related blog posts

Microsoft Research Blog Nov 12, 2026

Microsoft Research Focus – Edition #98

What's new in research at Microsoft? Host Anson Ho explores the latest, including AI-powered universal translation, a breakthrough in a 31-year-old mathematics challenge, and advances making AI coding agents faster and more efficient.  The post Microsoft Research Focus – Edition #98 appeared first on Microsoft Research.

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.