Designing for knowledge retention in STEM oriented project-based learning: A design based study of the SCOPE model
Abstract
Project-based learning despite its importance for sustaining conceptual understanding beyond immediate classroom performance. This study aimed to develop and evaluate the SCOPE model (Stimulation, Collaboration, Observation, Project, and Evaluation), a STEM-oriented instructional model that explicitly integrates retention-oriented cognitive processes into project-based learning. A Design-Based Research approach, operationalized through the Plomp development model, was implemented in two public primary schools involving 42 fifth-grade students. The study consisted of preliminary research, iterative prototyping, and assessment phases. Data were collected through expert validation, practicality questionnaires, classroom observations, and quasi-experimental testing to examine students’ critical thinking and knowledge retention. The findings showed that the SCOPE model achieved high validity (Aiken’s V = 0.85–0.88) and high classroom practicality, with student-material practicality increasing from 85.00% to 86.46% and teacher-guide practicality reaching 88.44%. ANCOVA results revealed a significant treatment effect for critical thinking (F(1, 39) = 9.411, p = .004). For knowledge retention, the experimental group obtained higher delayed post-test scores than the control group, although the adjusted ANCOVA result did not reach statistical significance (F(1, 39) = 2.932, p = .095), indicating a positive retention trend rather than conclusive evidence of a treatment effect. These findings suggest that integrating activation, elaboration, conceptual encoding, authentic application, and retrieval within STEM-oriented PjBL may support higher-order thinking and potentially contribute to more durable learning. The SCOPE model offers a theoretically informed and practically applicable framework for retention-oriented STEM instruction.