Skip to content

ON AI AND SOME PHILOSOPHICAL CHALLENGES

Sep 2026 · Communication & Cognition · 0 citations

TL;DR

A unified vision is offered: intelligence arises from constrained architectures and emergent patterns, and as AI systems become more autonomous, they may require surrogate forms of consciousness to handle complex, real-world challenges—though these will never fully replicate the biological original.

Abstract

This paper consists of two interconnected parts, both challenging mainstream computational views of mind and intelligence. In the first part, the author argues for a fundamental reconceptualization of cognition. He contends that the success of neural network-based AI and the universal properties of human language expose key limitations of classical computational theories of mind. Instead of viewing intelligence as rule-based symbol manipulation, he proposes that cognitive abilities emerge from architecturally constrained networks that mediate between analog and digital representations. This framework reconciles connectionist and universal-grammar approaches, suggesting that learning, innateness, and representation are best understood through structural constraints and emergent dynamics. Intelligence—whether biological or artificial—should therefore be seen as a product of architecture and emergence, not of explicit computation. In the second part, the authors examine the functional role of consciousness in biological organisms. They observe that current AI systems lack consciousness, but argue that consciousness-like mechanisms, such as real-time processing, reflexive awareness, and integrative functions, may become essential for AI systems that need to survive and adapt in dynamic, threatening environments. While they outline potential pathways for implementing such features, they also stress that artificial analogues would remain fundamentally different from biological consciousness. 156 Taken together, the paper offers a unified vision: intelligence arises from constrained architectures and emergent patterns, and as AI systems become more autonomous, they may require surrogate forms of consciousness to handle complex, real-world challenges—though these will never fully replicate the biological original.

View source

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Mind versus machine: can biological models of the mind inspire machine intelligence design?

The Modular Cognition Framework is an account of cognition in the mind and not in the brain, and includes a clear delineation of the two intimately related concepts, mind and brain, and a definition of their relationship.

M. Sharwood Smith · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Artificial Intelligence and Subtle Phenomena: Theoretical Perspectives on Representation and Reality

It is argued that this convergence of computation and subtle perception requires a revisioning of both AI architecture and human-machine interaction paradigms, positioning AI as a possible participant rather than merely a tool in the field of lived cognition.

D. Ene · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Alienated Intelligence

The concept of “alienated intelligence” is introduced to critically examine contemporary cultural perceptions of artificial intelligence to argue that certain visions of AI function as cultural projections of human cognitive capacities that become externalized, idealized, and reified in technological systems.

Jakub Walicki · 0 citations
#artificial intelligence Preprint Oct 2026

Artificial Intelligence and the New Science of Culture

This work examines generative AI agents as simulators of human subjectivity and as a qualitatively new coordinating substrate whose insertion into social life introduces evolutionary dynamics unprecedented in human cultural history.

Douglas Guilbeault, Bhargav Srinivasa Desikan, James A. Evans · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Machine consciousness, behaviorist epistemology, and the economics of replacing human roles

Whether artificial intelligence (AI) can be conscious is usually treated as a question for philosophers of mind, and the replacement of human labor by AI as a question for economists. This article argues that the two questions are entangled and that their separation is an artifact of the epistemology of modern economic...

Siti Hurul Aini · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.