Assessing Computational Models for Pharmacogenomic Variant Interpretation

Abstract

Accurately predicting the effects of pharmacogenomic variants is essential for the development of personalized therapeutic strategies, as genetic variability can influence drug response differently across patients. Here, we assessed several computational approaches using a dataset of pharmacogenomic variants with either clinical annotations or functional characterization by deep mutational scanning, compiled from the literature, with an additional focus on CYP2C9, a clinically relevant drug-metabolizing enzyme. Our results show that, despite recent methodological advances, substantial room for improvement remains. In particular, current methods struggle to distinguish gain-of-function variants associated with increased drug clearance and fast-metabolizer phenotypes from neutral variants, whereas loss-of-function variants that reduce drug clearance are predicted more accurately. The integration of structural and evolutionary information appears to be a key strategy for improving performance, with the coevolution-based StructureDCA method achieving the highest accuracy compared with classical genetic variant-effect predictors and recent deep learning approaches, including the pathogenic-variant predictor AlphaMissense and general protein language model–based methods. Finally, our results indicate that computational models can complement in vitro experiments in clinical variant interpretation, as StructureDCA predictions showed better agreement with clinically annotated phenotypes than large-scale deep mutational scanning data in several cases.