Skip to content
Review Open access

Planning in Project Management: Human vs Artificial Intelligence-driven

2026 · International Journal of Business and Economic Sciences Applied Research · Vol 19, pp. 7-30 · 0 citations

TL;DR

The study concludes that future project management practices can benefit from hybrid approaches, where AI augments human decision-making that could lead to successful completion of the projects.

Abstract

Purpose: This paper presents a comparative case study on project planning using two distinct approaches: the traditional human-driven method and an AI-assisted method. The study utilizes a publicly shared requirements for a software project, with the scope limited to the planning phase of the project. In the first scenario, the planning was performed by an experienced PMP-Certified Project Manager, with over seven years of practice, applying industry best practices, Project Management Body of Knowledge guidelines and professional judgement to create a structured plan. In the second scenario, the same requirements were processed through an AI-driven approach, using ChatGPT as a conversational tool, with results obtained through multiple prompt iterations. The outputs were analyzed comparatively, focusing on differences in structure, completeness, and adaptability of the proposed plans. A SWOT analysis was then conducted to evaluate strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats of both approaches. Findings suggest that while the human-driven approach offers a context-aware prioritization, tailored approach and comprehensive stakeholder integration, the AI-generated plan demonstrates rapid structuring and access to vast knowledge base. This work highlights the complementary potential of combining human expertise with AI support in project planning and accelerate the process, providing a broader perspective. While AI might lack contextual sensitivity and domain-specific prioritization that experienced project managers provide, the human expertise can ensure adaptability and creativity, but may be limited by personal experience or oversight. The study concludes that future project management practices can benefit from hybrid approaches, where AI augments human decision-making that could lead to successful completion of the projects. Design/methodology/approach: In this article it will be presented a proposed study case that will compare a phase in project management created by two different entities: a human professional in the field and in comparison, an AI generative tool (ChatGPT-5 model). The study case was applied on a random search for a public official requirement, and selected the first result returned when searching after Software Requirements Specification. The proposed protocol for the analysis follows Yin R. (2003) recommendations. Based on the explanation from his book, the study case starts with formulating the research question, then selection criteria of the study case, study case questions, delimitation of the study case, collection of the data and the results of the analysis of the data. Findings: The proposed study case question is: “How it is different the planning done by a human compared with an artificial intelligence, in terms of structure, sequencing, logic, time, completeness of the documents proposed, compared with project management best practices?”. The results differ in output size (10 pages and 17 annexes vs 20 pages), tool utilization (different tool vs no tool), time invested (3 days vs 1 hour), proposed deliverables, context relevance (tailored vs general information) and completeness (attached annexes vs enumerated). The findings were provided considering the same input and comparing the output received from both actors, emphasising the idea that the utilization of a generative AI tool enhance and complements the role of the human project manager. Although the project manager human is constrained to his experience, the help of the AI tool can be effective by leveraging extensive knowledge. Research limitations/implications: The sample size is small and includes only one human project manager, who is also one of the co-authors. Future research could involve multiple AI tools and a larger number of project managers working with the same requirements, allowing comparison across professionals. In addition, future studies could incorporate external expert reviews to validate plans generated by the human professional. Another proposal to extend this study could also be expanded to include multiple project documents rather than a single case. It can be considered as another limitation that the planning activity was created by a project manager and not by multiple participants with different roles. In companies, the planning typically involves contributions from various roles, such as business analysts for requirement breakdown or development teams for effort estimation. Further limitation concerns are related to the quality of the plan generated by the AI that depends heavily on the prompts provided. Since prompting skills vary with the user’s experience, the outputs may differ across individuals. Considering the experience of the person that introduces the prompting, the quality of the result can be different. Originality/value: The planification phase can be the most time-consuming and needs extensive project management knowledge. At the same time, there is growing discussion nowadays about AI and its impact on the workplace of project management field. In this study the aim was to search for empirical evidence on whether artificial intelligence can truly replicate expert human reasoning in project management planning. The results were presented between the two actors using narrative analysis, comparative analysis, benchmark analysis and SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) analysis, considering the PMBOK guide as a framework. There were also presented responses to the proposed questions. This case study would likely present different results in six months or in one to two years and it will be interesting to document how the impact of AI is evolving and it is integrated into real life projects.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Developing a Roadmap to an AI-first Organization: A Case Study in Embedded Software Development

A case study of a large embedded systems company and its transition toward becoming an AI-first organization, with implications for federated AI team formation, human-in-the-loop practices in such an organization, and the sustainable adoption of AI agents in embedded software engineering.

V. Kjellberg, Srijita Basu, Si-Min Sun et al. · 0 citations
Review Sep 2026

Artificial intelligence in project work: reshaping communication, coordination and problem-solving in project teams

It is shown that AI reshapes the nature of project work by relocating professional judgement from direct production towards evaluating, adapting, and integrating AI-supported outputs across communication, coordination, and problem-solving activities.

V. Dutot, M. Doargajudhur · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Universal planning errors: from a typology to a working tool for the project manager

This article is devoted to universal mistakes of planning, that arise during the work on a project. Inconsistencies between project planning documents arise in the first days of a project and recur regardless of industry, scale or planning technique, yet stay invisible when a document is read alone: each follows its ow...

J. A. Serebryakov · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

AI-Driven Project Management Knowledge Systems: Developing a Lora-Fine-Tuned Chatbot Using a Large-Scale Domain Dataset

Today’s project environments are at the intersection of information-intensive fields, including methodology management, risk analysis, resource planning, and cost control. Therefore, rapid and contextually sensitive access to accurate information is critical for professionals. The static structure of traditional inform...

Rabia Kalyon, Ç. Elmas · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

DRIVERS AND BARRIERS TO ADOPTING ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE PRACTICES IN MANAGING PROJECTS: A SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW THROUGH THE TOE FRAMEWORK

This study examines the main drivers and barriers influencing the adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) in project management, with a specific focus on emerging market conditions. The research is based on a systematic literature review conducted in accordance with the PRISMA 2020 guidelines. The final sample include...

A. B. Demeukhan, A. Zhumabayeva · 0 citations
Open access 2026

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN RECRUITMENT SYSTEMS: EVALUATION METHODOLOGY AND PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

The proposed methodology may support HR managers in selecting and implementing AI-based recruitment systems by enabling a structured assessment of system functionalities, organizational fit, and maturity level, and reduce implementation risks resulting from misalignment between technology and HR processes.

Jolanta Bartkowiak, D. Bąk-Grabowska · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.